撤稿!一篇离奇的论文消失了……

  • Colin
  • 0

来源 | 中外学术情报

编辑 | 学术君


嘘~不要告诉别人

  拉至文末有赠书福利! 


本社讯:4月8日,外媒RetractionWatch报道了一条撤稿消息:中文核心期刊《中国针灸》曾于2017年发表的一篇论文——《试论“量子纠缠”与针灸》,消失了。


2018年9月,这篇论文曾经在微博上引起关注和热议。文中,作者王军等人猜想,直系亲属间存在量子纠缠现象,父母生病了,给子女针灸就可以治疗;子女生病了,给父母针灸即可治疗;甚至兄弟姊妹之间可以实现针灸互治。然而被网络曝出后,这一结论广受质疑。



该文摘要称:


“量子纠缠理论是近代物理学的新发现, 当前已获得世人广泛关注。笔者通过学习量子理论, 发现量子的许多特性在中医、针灸理论与临床中得到体现, 例如量子纠缠现象与中医学中整体观念、阴阳学说、标本根结等理论可以相互印证, 能解释针灸临床中难以解释的针刺瞬时取效、一病多穴、特效穴等临床现象。基于这一理论, 笔者运用量子纠缠理论实现针灸临床的直系亲属互治, 且效果显著, 结果提示疾病与直系亲属的相应腧穴之间存在着量子纠缠的耦合关系。笔者认为, 本研究的发现将有利于拓展针灸临床的治疗途径, 也有助于丰富疾病预防的理念。”


在争议被引爆后,2018年9月16日,论文作者所在单位北京中医药大学东直门医院发表声明,表示该论文并非最终临床研究报告,对临床医疗尚不具备指导性。声明强调,坚决反对任何不负责任、不严谨和夸大中医药疗效的言论和观点。



而就在4月8号这天,国外媒体RetractionWatch关注并报道了这一中文期刊论文被撤稿的消息。



以下为报道原文:


Last year a Beijing doctor said he was “speechless” after reading a study.


The study in question, published in Chinese Acupuncture & Moxibustionin 2017, was titled “Discussion on quantum entanglement theory and acupuncture.” Dr. Zeng, the Beijing doctor, was among a number of critics quoted in September 2018 by What’s On Weibo, which reports on social media happenings in China:

To suggest that when children fall ill, their parents just need to undergo some acupuncture and they’ll be fine, because there is ‘quantum entanglement’ (量子纠缠) among blood kins – saying that acupuncture on the parents is equal to acupuncture on the children -, this is really serious. According to this theory, we might as well cancel pediatrics.

It was not pediatrics that was canceled, however. The paper has been retracted and has disappeared, although we don’t quite know why. According to a scant retraction notice published on PubMed:

The article “Discussion on quantum entanglement theory and acupuncture” (doi: 10.13703/j.0255-2930.2017.11.026, published in Zhongguo Zhen Jiu 2017,37(11):1233-1237) has some defects, and the author of the article proposes to withdraw the manuscript. According to the retraction provisions of our journal, it is considered that the author’s application complies with the relevant provisions and our journal agrees to withdraw the draft.

We’ve been unable to find contact information for the authors of the study, who are based at Beijing’s Dongzhimen Hospital and the Beijing University of Chinese Medicine.


Wen Yan Qi, writing in Waonews last year, said:

If you can browse the paper entitled “On Quantum Entanglement and Acupuncture”, it is not difficult to find that there are many places that do not conform to scientific logic. The author applies the concept of quantum entanglement, which is called “the phenomenon of quantum interaction in the system”, to the mother and son who were once a “whole” and uses the phenomenon of “telepathy” which has not been scientifically proven as evidence to prove the viewpoint that “mutual treatment of acupuncture and moxibustion by relatives” is effective. On the whole, the paper seems to be “justified”, but it is actually the result of “changing concepts” and “copying rigidly”.


对此,您怎么看?欢迎留言。



 赠 书 福 利 


昨日小编疏忽

推送未排版的文章

经粉丝提醒已及时删除

已对小编进行严格教育

在此也向大家表示歉意????


作为一点小补偿

参与本文末留言互动

我们将选取三位幸运儿

各赠送好书1本


以上书籍任选一本

明日公布获奖名单


本文来源:中外学术情报

转载本文请联系原作者获取授权,同时请注明本文来源。


如果不想错过每日精彩

一定要星标置顶哟~ 


后台回复关键词:福利

学术君精选


师从施一公,从造纸工人到国际知名科学家,这是他的科研之路

现阶段硕士的困境:读博没决心,不读也闹心…

88岁院士捐毕生积蓄150万做奖学金,她说了一句话…


▼ 点击「阅读原文」,获取更多免费资源

本篇文章来源于微信公众号: 学术资源大全

相关文章

版权声明:

本网站(网站地址)刊载的所有内容,包括文字、图片、音频、视频、软件、程序、以及网页版式设计等均在网上搜集。

访问者可将本网站提供的内容或服务用于个人学习、研究或欣赏,以及其他非商业性或非盈利性用途,但同时应遵守著作权法及其他相关法律的规定,不得侵犯本网站及相关权利人的合法权利。除此以外,将本网站任何内容或服务用于其他用途时,须征得本网站及相关权利人的书面许可,并支付报酬。

本网站内容原作者如不愿意在本网站刊登内容,请及时通知本站,予以删除。